Despite Powys County Council claiming that the new recycling booking system has been working well, results from a survey carried out by Senedd Member Russell George, show the public are not convinced.
Since April 1st 2025, Powys residents have been required to book appointments to access recycling centres, with visits limited to just 10 minutes. The changes also included the introduction of charges for disposing of DIY waste, moves that had sparked widespread criticism.
When plans were first announced, Mr George expressed concern about a similar scheme in Shropshire that was later reversed due to a backlash from residents and businesses.
The Montgomeryshire MS had also raised concerns with the Deputy First Minister, Huw Irranca-Davies MS in the Senedd.
A survey conducted by Mr George between April and July found overwhelming public opposition to the new policy:
- 87% of respondents were highly concerned about the new system and charges
- 94% did not believe the changes would improve recycling rates
- 91% opposed DIY waste charges
- 96% expected an increase in fly-tipping
- 88% feared more garden waste would be burned, affecting air quality and health
Welsh Conservative councillors on Powys County Council had attempted to halt the changes and continue to oppose both the booking system and the charges that were introduced. Last month (July), County Councillors opposing the changes successfully won a motion calling for a formal review within six months of the scheme’s launch. That review will now take place in Autumn 2025.
Mr George has welcomed the news that Powys County Council has agreed to conduct a review of the system later this year, after pressure from Councillors and public dissatisfaction.
Commenting, Russell George MS said:
“The introduction of a time-limited, appointment only system creates significant barriers for residents trying to dispose of their waste responsibly. It's not only inconvenient, it risks deterring people entirely, and most worryingly, could lead to an increase in fly-tipping and illegal burning of waste.
“We’ve already seen neighbouring Shropshire scrap a similar system after public backlash. Powys risks making the same mistake.
“Wales is already a recycling leader, yet these new measures undermine that progress by putting obstacles in residents’ way.
“I am pleased that a review will take place later this year, but I hope the Council’s cabinet will take this review seriously.
“Following my survey, the message from the public is crystal clear. This scheme is deeply unpopular and counterproductive. Instead of encouraging recycling, it risks doing real harm to our environment and public health.
Trelystan and Trewern County Councillor Amanda Jenner said:
“Residents are telling us loud and clear that the new booking and charging rules make recycling more difficult, not easier.
‘’ The reality is that this one-size-fits-all approach is completely unsuitable for a rural county like Powys, where access and flexibility are essential.
‘’ I am particularly concerned about the potential rise in fly-tipping and backyard burning, which not only damages our environment but also puts added pressure on council services.
“That’s why my colleagues and I brought a motion to Council calling for a proper review. I welcome the fact that this will now take place in the autumn, and I will continue working with Russell George MS and fellow councillors to make sure the voices of Powys residents are heard.”